Quick Verdict · REV-2026-046
Heart & Soil is the best beef organ supplement for athletes and the most comprehensive nose-to-tail formula on the market. The Informed Sport certification is decisive for drug-tested competitors — no other organ supplement offers this.
The main weakness is the proprietary blend: without disclosed organ doses, you cannot calculate exact retinol intake, which matters for safety. For non-athletes, Ancestral Supplements offers comparable sourcing quality at a lower price. For everyone who wants the broadest organ nutrition with third-party verification, Heart & Soil is the clear choice.
formula
9.0
transparency
8.5
verification
9.5
value
7.0
practical
8.5
What Is Heart & Soil Beef Organs?
Heart & Soil was founded by Dr. Paul Saladino — a physician best known for advocating the carnivore diet and the nutritional density of nose-to-tail eating. The Beef Organs product is the brand's flagship: a five-organ freeze-dried blend designed to deliver the complete nutritional spectrum of ancestral organ consumption in capsule form.
The formula includes beef liver, beef heart, beef kidney, beef spleen, and beef pancreas. Each organ contributes nutrients the others lack: liver provides retinol, B12, and heme iron; heart is the primary dietary source of CoQ10; kidney adds selenium and riboflavin; spleen contributes tuftsin and additional heme iron; pancreas provides enzyme precursors and B vitamins.
The Informed Sport certification distinguishes Heart & Soil from every other organ supplement in this category. Every batch is independently tested for over 200 WADA-prohibited substances. For drug-tested athletes, this is the only verifiably safe option.
Regenerative vs Organic vs Grass-Fed
Heart & Soil's US regenerative sourcing goes beyond USDA Organic. Regenerative agriculture requires active soil health improvement through managed grazing, reduced tillage, and carbon sequestration. Farm partners are named on the brand's website — this level of supply chain transparency is rare in the organ supplement category.
FSP Score Breakdown
FSP v2.1 composite: 8.00/10 → editorial score: 9/10. Weighting: Formula 35% · Transparency 25% · Verification 20% · Value 12% · Practical 8%.
Red & Green Flags
Supplement Facts
Key Nutrients per Serving
Approximate values per 6-capsule serving based on known nutrient density of these organs. Lower retinol estimates reflect dilution across 5 organs vs a single-organ liver product.
Values are estimates from published organ nutrient density data. Actual values vary by batch, season, and animal. Exact organ-to-organ ratios are not disclosed (proprietary blend).
Lab Data & Verification
Heart & Soil holds the highest verification standard available for organ supplements — Informed Sport certification. Every batch is independently tested before release.
Certified
Every batch — 200+ WADA substances
Tested
Below action level
Tested
Below action level
Tested
Below action level
Tested
Below action level
Undisclosed
Proprietary blend
Verify certification: Go to informed-sport.com/certified-productsand search for Heart & Soil to confirm current batch certification status. Informed Sport publishes a searchable database of all certified products.
Marketing Claim Audit
How to Take It
Standard dose
6 capsules daily with your largest meal. Dr. Saladino recommends taking with food to support digestion of the fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, K2) present in organ tissue.
Starting out
Start with 3 capsules for the first 1–2 weeks if you are new to organ supplements. Some people experience mild digestive adjustment — this usually resolves in 5–7 days.
Timing
With food, always. Fat-soluble vitamins require dietary fat for absorption. Any fat-containing meal works.
Do not exceed
6 caps without medical guidance. At 6 caps, retinol intake from the liver fraction is likely well below the 10,000 IU/day UL. At 12 caps (sometimes suggested in ancestral health circles), this needs monitoring.
Consistent daily use
More important than timing. Organ nutrition builds gradually — consistent daily use maintains circulating nutrient levels better than sporadic high-dose days.
vs. Competitors
Heart & Soil is the premium tier in this roundup. Key differentiators are Informed Sport certification, US regenerative sourcing, and the 5-organ formula.
| Heart & Soil | Ancestral Supps | Left Coast Perf. | Perfect Supps | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FSP Score | 9/10 ★ | 8/10 | 8/10 | 8/10 |
| Organs | 5 (full blend) | 1 (liver) | 5 (full blend) | 1 (liver) |
| Sourcing | US Regenerative | NZ Grass-Fed | NZ Grass-Fed | Brazil Organic |
| Certification | Informed Sport | Heavy metal COA | None | USDA Organic |
| Price / serving | $1.83 | $1.50 | $0.39 | $0.33 |
| Dose disclosure | Proprietary blend | Single ingredient | Proprietary blend | Single ingredient |
| Athletes safe | Yes (verified) | No cert | No cert | No cert |
Prices verified May 2026. Heart & Soil sold direct at heartandsoil.co — check site for current pricing and bundles.
Products at a Glance
Top organ supplements compared — prices verified May 2026.
Pros & Cons
Strengths
- Only Informed Sport certified beef organ supplement
- Comprehensive 5-organ nose-to-tail formula
- US regenerative farm sourcing — named farms on website
- Dr. Saladino's clinical formulation expertise
- Heavy metal COA available on request
Limitations
- Proprietary blend — individual organ doses undisclosed
- Most expensive in category at $1.83/serving
- Retinol calculation impossible without organ-dose disclosure
Safety & Vitamin A
The proprietary blend makes retinol calculation impossible — a notable concern given Vitamin A's toxicity potential.
Pregnant women: consult your OB/GYN before use
The proprietary blend in Heart & Soil makes it impossible to calculate exact retinol intake — a critical consideration given retinol's teratogenic potential above 10,000 IU/day. For pregnant women, a product with disclosed ingredient doses is safer.
At 6 caps/day: likely safe for most healthy adults
A 5-organ blend distributes the 3g across five tissues. The liver fraction is likely 600mg or less — significantly less retinol than a single-organ liver product at the same total dose.
With a daily multivitamin: check your total retinol
Many multivitamins contain 750–1,500 mcg RAE of preformed Vitamin A. Combined with organ supplements, total intake approaches the 3,000 mcg UL. Monitor total retinol from all sources.
For athletes: Informed Sport provides safety assurance
The Informed Sport certification verifies every batch for WADA-prohibited substances. For drug-tested athletes, this is the decisive factor — no other organ supplement offers this assurance.
Price & Value
180 caps (30 sv)
$55
Standard bottle
Subscribe & Save
~$47–50/mo
~15% off, cancellable
Bundle options
Varies
Check heartandsoil.co
Prices verified May 2026 at heartandsoil.co. International shipping available.
Where to Buy
Heart & Soil website (heartandsoil.co)
RecommendedPrimary channel. Subscribe & Save available. Bundles and product stacks. Direct brand support for COA requests.
$55
Shop NowAmazon US
Available but often slightly higher than direct. Verify the seller is Heart & Soil directly. Informed Sport certification applies regardless of where you buy — the batch certification travels with the product.
$55–60
Shop NowFAQ
Final Verdict · REV-2026-046
The best organ supplement for athletes. Overpriced for everyone else.
Heart & Soil earns a 9/10 for delivering the broadest organ nutrition, the highest verification standard (Informed Sport), and credible US regenerative sourcing. The proprietary blend and premium price are its only real weaknesses — and for athletes who need batch drug testing, neither matters.
For general consumers, Ancestral Supplements at $1.50/serving is the better value play. But if you compete in a tested sport, Heart & Soil is non-negotiable — it is the only organ supplement with Informed Sport certification.
Research References
- Spitze AR et al. (2003). Taurine and carnosine content of various mammalian tissues. JAVMA. — Referenced for organ nutrient density. ↗
- Mattila P et al. (2001). Contents of nutrients and antinutritional factors in conventional and organically produced foods. Eur J Nutr. — Nutrient comparison. ↗
- USDA FoodData Central. Beef, variety meats and by-products, liver, raw. FDC ID: 174469. ↗
- Institute of Medicine. Dietary Reference Intakes for Vitamin A. National Academies Press, 2001. Tolerable Upper Intake Level for preformed retinol: 10,000 IU/day. ↗
- Informed Sport. Certification and batch testing methodology. informed-sport.com. ↗
